In Science, March 9, 1888, we read of a block of limestone, said to have fallen near Middleburgh, Florida. It was exhibited at the Sub-tropical Exposition, at Jacksonville. The writer, in Science, denies that it fell from the sky. His reasoning is: There is no limestone in the sky; Therefore this limestone did not fall from the sky.
Better reasoning I cannot conceive of — because we see that a final major premise — universal — true — would include all things: that, then, would leave nothing to reason about — so then that all reasoning must be based upon “something” not universal, or only a phantom intermediate to the two finalities of nothingness and allness, or negativeness and positiveness.
La Nature 1890-2-127:
Fall, at Pel-et-Der (L’Aube) France, June 6, 1890, of limestone pebbles. Identified with limestone at Chateau Landon — or up and down in a whirlwind. But they fell with hail — which, in June, could not very well be identified with ice from Chateau-Landon. Coincidence, perhaps.
Upon page 70, Science Gossip, 1887, the Editor says, of a stone that was reported to have fallen at Little Lever, England, that a sample had been sent to him. It was sandstone. Therefore it had not fallen, but had been on the ground in the first place. But, upon page 140, Science Gossip, 1887, is an account of “a large, smooth, waterworn, gritty sandstone pebble” that had been found in the wood of a full-grown beech tree. Looks to me as if it had fallen red-hot, and had penetrated the tree with high velocity. But I have never heard of anything falling red-hot from a whirlwind –
The wood around this sandstone pebble was black, as if charred.
Dr. Farrington, for instance, in his books, does not even mention sandstone. However, the British Association, though reluctant, is less exclusive: Report of 1860, p. 107: substance about the size of a duck’s egg, that fell at Raphoe, Ireland, June 9, 1860 — date questioned. It is not definitely said that this substance was sandstone, but that it “resembled” friable sandstone.
(Aus “The Book Of The Damned“, 1919)
